NETWORK18

Hot Topics » Gorkhaland Row | Asia Cup Subscribe » IBNLive Newsletter | RSS | Podcast

Amrita Tripathi

Ads by Google

Monday , April 28, 2008 at 12 : 08

Font Size A+A-

Save the Cheerleader, Save the World


Email PrintBlog
Ads by Google

Before you start frothing at the mouth, all you self-declared guardians of all that's pure, it's a quote from Heroes (Tagline Season 1...But I digress.)

Why cheerleaders are the centre of a moral debate, is beyond me -- besides the obvious that is, the usual chest-beating, vote-banking, playing on insecurities and other nonsense the country has come to expect and take in its stride...and almost forget that there are real issues out there.

Is there nothing better to talk about in this whole cricket revolution? Apart from entertainment vs sport. Vs masala. Vs girls in short skirts.

I mean, are they immoral? Are they taking part in something immoral? I don't even want to get started on all that's wrong with the comparison to bar girls... there's no winning arguments with the irrational. Why are the players in this debate getting it all in a twist over this of all things?

Have they even been watching your Bollywood stars of late? Gyrating away in skimpy nothings, and this isn't just the movies, but the shows, on TV... it's everywhere... we're encouraging kids to emulate them too, after all. It's nothing new at all. But oh it's fine, they're good desi girls, and they won't kiss, or shock-horror give the impression of being anything but virginal, so they're not the issue. Is that it?

Do I even like cheerleaders? Not particularly - but that's not even the point. They're out there doing what cheerleaders do - entertaining you, the audience, getting that ra-ra spirit going for the boys out there on the field or pitch or what-have-you, boosting morale and so on.

Really in this debate, the side you're coming on, it really shows what you're bringing to the table... what's in your own head.

Do cheerleaders know they're attractive - hell, yeah! Forget real games abroad, anyone who's seen anything of Hollywood, from teen dramas to soaps or yeah, Heroes... you know it's all tied up with popularity, being on display, being attractive, and well yes, agile. Are they there to titillate - well that's an open debate.

But what they're NOT there to do, and for that my heart does go out to all these phirang ladies in short tops and skirts, they're not there to put up with what we're calling "lewd comments"... another massive and insulting understatement, much like "eve-teasing".

You know what it is, if you've ever walked the streets of Delhi, or any of a half-dozen big cities in this country, if you've ever taken public transport, if you've ever had the temerity to go to a club without a male escort (and even then sometimes), hell if you've ever looked like a girl in this country.

You know the shame, the flame of red shooting up your face when you understand what they're saying, that it somehow seems a reflection on you, even when it's not - rationally, you know that.

Rationally you know, you have to pick your battles, but realistically, it's not often that you win.

You know you're beaten, when as a chick you walk eyes downcast, trying to avoid all kinds of eye contact. You know it's out there, this haze of sexual repression and serious threat to your physical well-being, but if you don't look, you won't see it. That's if you're lucky.

So it's not really about just saving the cheerleaders, you know, I mean at the end of the day, they're going to pack up and go home.

I think if anything, we should be addressing that mass of frustration and sexual repression that pervades everything that has to do with public space. Re-education even - of course when authorities are not even comfortable getting young people sensitised through sex education programmes, this is going to be a stretch...

But at least don't confuse the issue - the real issue, that is, not whether cheer-leading is anathema to the Indian spirit.

It's called sexual harassment and it's not ok.

Total Comments: 64

CollapsePosted : By Shiladitya

You know what is the problem with us? We always try to cover up our weaknesses and shortcomings with the facade of 'culture'. What is our culture? And who made u the guardian of our culture? Let people decide for themselves. I do not want to justify the cheer leading in IPL with examples of bollywood songs. That is pointless. My level of moral outrage can be vastly different from yours. But learn to live with that. And tell me frankly, don't u enjoy look at the cheerleaders when nobody is watching you? ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By PHILIP

We see very little of the cheer leaders on the tv . Most of the intervening time between play is taken up with ads , which we have seen many many times and are irritated to see again . I have a suggestion to the advertisers , why not show us the cheer leaders in the time you have bought and scribble on the screen that your product is sponsoring it . That way we may start having a soft corner for your product rather than the present irritated feeling. ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By Nitesh

I agree with most of the points you have made. The moral police which talks of %22Indian culture%22 is the same which isnt even literate and doesnt even have a college degree. They are the same people who were ok with Aishwarya Rai wearing even less in Dhoom 2, or Kareena Kapoor in a bikini in Tashan. of course,they make the presumption that Indian women wearing less is not demeaning culture, but foriegn cheerleaders is. There is a hint of male chavaunism, sexual repression and even racism in it. The only problem I have is the camera, which after every boundary, goes up their skirts. Show them dancing, but maybe the camera could be positioned better, so that parents watching with kids couldbe a little more comfortable?I have read some comments which say it is ok if there were Indian women in place of the American cheerleaders, which suggests either a %22Indians are better than others%22 racist feeling or %22Indian women can demean themselves, it doesnt matter%22 male chavaunism. The fact that we have actually spent so muchtime debating this rather building working on spreading primary education(remember the problem of reservation? how primary education would have led to it being not needed?), or the rising food prices(isnt this the aam aadmi govt?) or global warming, something which is affecting us right now. You know, meaningful stuff which people elected them to sort out. The US sat and talked about gays and evolution and ignored its infrastructure problems after 2002, and look where it is today after 8 years of Bush. Something similar is happening here, as we spend more time debating whether cheerleaders are okay or not. Soon we will be debating who let the dogs out. Probably our politicians need a lesson in good governence. Compulsory college education for politicians anyone? ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By Tejas

And..some food for thoughts!What about the semi-clad/nude saadhus roaming on our streets?What if the cheerleaders were semi clad guys?Have fun watching the game, people!! :) ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By krishnabaalu

Fine then there is a valid point from our perspective too! dear pl listen.You being a woman how can you degrade the status of woman??My point is why cheer leaders are only should be females? why not alos males? This is where exacttly i differ.KRISHNA BAALU ...Reply

All the content posted in the 'IBN Blogs' section, unless specified otherwise, are made by CNN-IBN employees. The content posted in 'IBN Blogs' does not follow routine internal CNN-IBN reviews and editorial processes and should be considered only as the views and opinions of the employees and not of CNN-IBN.

About Us | Disclaimer | Careers @ IBN | RSS | Podcast | Contact Us | Feedback | Advertise With Us

© 2008 IBNLive.com India. All Rights Reserved. A Web18 Venture