Read
Listen
Watch
Play
Find
Mail
Biggboss2      

NETWORK18

News Videos Blogs

What’s Hot » Monica out of Bigg Boss 2 | Save Bihar

Masand's Verdict» A Wednesday | Tahaan

Suhasini Haidar

Ads by Google

Saturday , January 05, 2008 at 10 : 16

Font Size A+A-

Bhuttos and Gandhis: Common Chord, Common Curse


Email PrintBlog
Ads by Google

As another Bhutto dies a violent death- the comparisons between that tragic dynasty in Pakistan and our own Gandhis have become the cliché with the most currency. I succumb too, because the similiarities are just incredible.

Both Rajiv Gandhi and Benazir Bhutto had a parent who was a Prime Minister- a Pakistani friend pointed out to me in fact that Indira Gandhi was killed by her bodyguards, and Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was sent to the gallows by the man who was in a manner of speaking was, as Army Chief, in charge of his protection. The death of both Indira and Zulfiqar didn't just change their children's lives, they changed the course of their countries' destiny.

Like Benazir, Rajiv Gandhi died in a suicide bombing. Like her son Bilawal, Rajiv's son Rahul was just about twenty, just beginning an undergraduate college degree abroad. Rajiv lost his brother in an aircrash that was a mystery for years, Benazir lost two brothers at a young age, both dying mysteriously.

While still in mourning for Indira and Zulfiqar respectively - Rajiv and Benazir had picked up the reins of their parties, leading them to victory in the first election they ran. The honeymoon with their electorate then souring as charges of corruption came to the fore. Both Rajiv and Benazir died while campaigning, the real tragedy in their deaths that both seemed to have learnt much from the mistakes they made during the first terms in office. Their unrealized potential, I think, was the biggest loss for the nations.

Outside Naudero House, where the Bhuttos live is the really unfortunate comparison. The similiarities between the way Larkana and Amethi remain undeveloped. Both constituencies of our dynasties are poor, with unbuilt roads, bad sanitation, erratic electricity and unfinished promises of modernization. Like Amethi, Larkana is dotted with technical institutes named after some member of the dynasty, but more often than not they represent a grant given to a favoured local leader of the party, and not a genuine initiative for change. I have also always wondered about the immense power of these families- that are known for their lifestyles abroad, yet are able to strike such a chord with the poorest person within their country. Rajiv had his Rolex, Benazir died with her Chanel glasses on- but both families can claim the underprivileged Aam Aadmi as their most ardent supporter. In Amethi, so many speak of their Tyag and Balidan, In Larkana, they repeatedly talk of Qurbani.

And as I walked into Naudero House Larkana- I saw the next parallel. In a corner of the yard outside what's known as Bhutto House (strangely, it was the maternal home of Zulfiqar's first wife Begum Ameer Bhutto, and not his at all), sat young Zulfiqar Jr. He is the son of Benazir's brother Murtaza and his wife Ghinwa. Relations between Ghinwa and Benazir had been bitter, and like Maneka Gandhi and her son Feroze Varun (also named after his grandfather), Ghinwa had been turfed out of the family home. The Gandhi-Bhutto mystique, is only transferable down one line, it seems.

Watching Asif Ali Zardari at the press conference that followed reading out Benazir's will, I couldn't help feeling Zardari had studied many of the parallels I had. And true enough, like Sonia Gandhi, he stepped down from the big position, perhaps to wield even more authority from behind the throne. I asked him the question directly, and Zardari smiled. He said Sonia was much more experienced than him, but his admiration for her clearly showed.

Young Bilawal too seemed aware that the odds of history remained stacked in favour of high office but against survival. In an answer to my question at the press conference he addressed, he said, "As we know, the chairmanship of the party is a position which is occupied by martyrs (exact quote)".

That then will remain the defining common chord of our political dynasties. With all the world at their command- they live with the constant knowledge it could end any day. And every event, personal or otherwise plays out on a screen that's much larger than life.

Total Comments: 64

CollapsePosted : By Ramchandra

One more thing that is common in them and that is both the dynasities have ruled their countries in a so called democratic constitution. Both the families have been burden to their countries.%22The Nehru%22 dynasity has has gifted india with the numerous unresolvable issues including the issue of kashmir. the bhuttos have ruled simmilarly in Pakistan and have used the ISI against India and they are now endorsed as moderate muslims. And do u know the worst part of the Gandhi family. Media,which is a symbol of freedom in a democracy, has been crazy about this family and has always endorsed the dynasty Nehru which is utterly shameless in a democracy. ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By Wajid Hashmi

I agree with ur view that fate has not been kind to either Rajiv Gandhi and Benazir.Both were extremely good loking and attracted the youths all over.Both had the inernational aura that is unmatchable.I sincerly pray to god to protect both Rahul and Bilawal from evil designs. ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By n.s.maunder

It is a tragedy that both the countries prefer to be ruled by dynasties.Soniaji has appointed a regent in manmohan singh as heir is not yet mature.Zardari is following her example.Luckily india got a good p.m. whome they wont elect even as an m.p. Let us wish same luck to Pakistan. ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By gurunath prakash

wa?whateva that means, how can you say this channel is a waste channel? I dont agree with a number of things so many channel airs including ibn but try to put your view rather than running it down... ...Reply

CollapsePosted : By gurunath prakash

Hey! Mr/Ms.Cheeky, its unfair to target Suhasini, she is so good with her article. Whats wrong with what she has written. You got to understand, she has a page or two to write...i know what you are aiming at, for that we need a book! Dont be a Pointing here.... ...Reply

All the content posted in the 'IBN Blogs' section, unless specified otherwise, are made by CNN-IBN employees. The content posted in 'IBN Blogs' does not follow routine internal CNN-IBN reviews and editorial processes and should be considered only as the views and opinions of the employees and not of CNN-IBN.

About Us | Disclaimer | Careers @ IBN | RSS | Podcast | Contact Us | Feedback | Advertise With Us

© 2008 IBNLive.com India. All Rights Reserved. A Web18 Venture