We should first accept that there is no eqality in many respects amongst human beings . Some are good at some works while some are good at some other works . However There should be reservations in all fields at the primary stages . And only those who qualify for further stage should be allowed to enter in the next stage. For stepping into the next stage , ther should be no reservation for anyone on any ground --neither on social [castes] ,nor on economical grounds . Donation seats , management quota etc. should also be stopped immediately .
( Posted: Tuesday , June 06, 2006 at 06:46 )
Mahesh
When the sunlight started to glimmer over india after years (decades) of mismanagment and dirty politics, the government is taking a strong step to make sure we go backward . . "A gaint leap backward"
Taking the existing "mis utilized" quota system by politicians for there own personal gains, people have suffered. Addendum to there agony the governmnet is taking additional bite into there living. If this goes on "God Bless India and its tradation"
Why was this quota system brought in? When will the retreat sound for this quota system ? When these are the days we have to see the retreat of the quota system the government and "presonal gain" politicians are taking the putting the wrong foot!!
When will this agony, acromony end ? When will india become free? Free where every induvidual has the right to live, live with dignity?
( Posted: Monday , June 05, 2006 at 18:14 )
rakesh
thank u mr.singh for being so considerateabout the future of the young people like us.iam a student tooo who is being deprived from seats besides getting good marks,b'coz iam a forward caste,if u ministers are not aware of the total percentage of obc's how do u reserve the seats for them.Is this b'coz of the improper parliamentary bills those were made or due to the improper leaders who rule our country.reservations shoud be there but reservations without a fixed percentage is not good for the other caste like me.Now even in the kerala C.E.T,the obc's who got 18000 as rank got into R.E.C,while those who got less than 1000 didnt get into R.E.C's,which shows the less able gets first rather than the more able.i would reccomend that reservation to those who are also good at studies should only be given them.raather than the one who aint eligible for it
( Posted: Monday , June 05, 2006 at 16:41 )
gs
dear thinkers of our nation ,
shouldnot we stop enterance tests as it is benifiting only rich and not talent,
today news items has sugested mass level coping and enterance paper leak of UP B.ed and ITI exams. think and get away from corrupt practise to the nation from money power.
( Posted: Monday , June 05, 2006 at 10:29 )
Raghavendra
This guy (why, the entire parliment) knows only votebank politics. They are effectively using the gifts bestowed on us by British (corruption, split and rule...). I hate to call these as ministers of our nation. I am ashamed to be ruled by these. I am going to vote this time.
( Posted: Sunday , June 04, 2006 at 21:54 )
gs
Well done Mr . Singh for the pride of India.
I am sure if a person who has done a fraud of rupees one lac, has indirectly killed minimum of 50 persons per month. Any reservation based of castism shall be opposed only when a law is passed to give death penalty to most corrupt 100 persons every year if they were involved in financial fraud / tax aviation. It is well known fact that poor is badly hit by corruption and most poor persons happened to be from SC/ST, OBC & rural Indians
Reservation for every caste in proportion to their population will eliminate corruption in entrance test for higher studies / job selection and will nurse actual talent from every caste and sector of Indian society.
Any actual taxpayer cannot pay the amount about Rs.100000/- for just preparation of entrance test of IIT, IIM &AIIMS. Under this conditions where money is the only criteria to get admission in to higher studies in India. That is why in the last 58 years not even a signal Indian is recognised for any scientific research at global level.
( Posted: Sunday , June 04, 2006 at 21:45 )
gs
Well done Mr . Singh for the pride of India.
The society, which headed by corrupt persons, let it be any sector govt. or private the only way-out to get some short of parity with mighty wealthy corrupt person by a poor person, is a reservation.
( Posted: Sunday , June 04, 2006 at 21:43 )
Amit Kulkarni
Mr. Arjun Singh has moved to this step just keeping the view of Elections in mind and nothing else. If he would reserved 10%-12% reservation for OBCs, it would have been justified. Giving weightge of 27% reservation clearly shows his intention and he had not have support of the parliament initially. He has done this in the interst of politics. This has nothing to do with the OBCs higher eduction. On the contrary this would deteriorate and underestimate thousands of students who are in the general category.
This needs deadly protest from the youths of India.
Definitely a wrong decision taken in view of political interest!!
( Posted: Sunday , June 04, 2006 at 21:12 )
Kurar Selvan
If you survey the Union Cabinet 81% of the ministers are from forward castes. 13% are SC/ST and only 6% belong to OBC. Mr. Arjun Singh should take note of this fact.
( Posted: Sunday , June 04, 2006 at 12:25 )
Dear Mr.As,
Would like to Ask you the follwing questions:
1. Have you passed your 10th Exams 2. If so, how many attempts you took? 3. If not, no more questions... you are qualified to be in parliament. 4. If you have really passed ur 10th. In how many subjects, you just scraped thru?
Oh I am sorry, before all these, I forgot to ask you, which *caste* do you belong?
Regrets, Raghu
( Posted by Raghu on )
H S Gill
This reservation is not for the benefit of intended people .It is for reaping political profits. It can only be justified on economical basis everyone from every cast and creed should be given help to attain the best education that is available in india.Then everybody should competefor whatever is going.A person`s off spring with very good job from reservation enjoys reservation.While a poor farmer or shopkeeper`s off spring who cannot afford basic educationcannot go nowhere.Polticians are creating another extremely backward class.It is 95% of rural population.The cosequences off the present policy is not hard to protect even more divided india.CAN POLITICANS PUT ABAN ON HOW LONG YOU CAN BE APOLTICAN OR 2ND GENERATION OF A FAMILY CAN BE BANNED FROM JOINING POLITICS ,MOST BENEFICIAN PROFESSION IN IINDIA SO FAR SINCE 1947.tUGLUKS OF MODERN TIMES BEWARE AND BE SENSIBLE, Hardev singh gill afford
Do not be rude to other users/authors or disrupt an ongoing conversation/debate. Do not use ethnic slurs, engage in personal insults or use objectionable language. Criticism, when constructive and non-disruptive is always welcome. Comments with links in them won't be published other than in cases of rare exceptions. Comments that include personal details such as postal addresses and telephone numbers will not be published. Keep the comments relevant to the topic as much as possible. Do not impersonate another reader or a public figure. Do try to use English to write your comments.
Please enable javascript in your browser to use this form.
Disclaimer
All the content posted under the 'Comments' category are made by the readers of CNN-IBN, unless specified otherwise. CNN-IBN is not responsible for the opinions of the readers and the content posted by the readers are not representative of the views and opinions of CNN-IBN.
Do not be rude to other users/authors or disrupt an ongoing conversation/debate.